Saturday, October 03, 2009


http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/03/us/03religion.html

Mr. Oren pulled to a stop, and as the children stayed in the car, the grown-ups gingerly padded into the sanctuary of Saints Peter and Paul Antiochian Orthodox Church....As he entered, a vespers service was under way. Maybe two dozen worshipers stood, chanting psalms and hymns. Incense filled the dark air. Icons of apostles and saints hung on the walls. The ancientness and austerity stood at a time-warp remove from the evangelical circles in which Mr. Oren traveled, so modern, extroverted and assertively relevant. “This was a Christianity I had never encountered before,” said Mr. Oren, 55, a marketing consultant in commercial construction. “I was frozen in my tracks. I felt like I was in the actual presence of God, almost as if I was in heaven...In 1995, he attended his first service at Holy Cross, an Antiochian church here, about 10 miles south of Baltimore. By late 1996, he was a regular, and in May 1997, he and his family converted and joined.

People used to find that in the Episcopal Church before the Church destroyed its liturgy, mounted a campaign to strip out every last bit of the numinous from its services and, most recently, began making efforts to simulate the style of successful evangelical churches in order to attract customers.

I thought seriously about joining an Orthodox church when I was in college and sometimes wish I had. My problem was the Filioque Clause. I still don't buy it, however the Anglican Church has been Filioque-optional since 1978 so that's no problem. The problem is that the Episcopal Church, which was once a wide tent with a little something for everyone is now split between a minority of churches drawn into the conservative evangelical orbit and the majority which don't do religion at all. They do "activities," of which the Sunday service is just one and by no means the most important.

I couldn't join an Orthodox church because they don't ordain women. Not that I care whether women are actually ordained or not: it's the principle of the thing. I can buy a lot of theology--at least I can plunk for theological claims and commit: metaphysics is always iffy and I'm used to it. But I cannot buy the claim that men and women are different in some metaphysically significant way. The issue isn't inequality, which doesn't particularly bother me, but la difference as such. Can't buy it any more than I could buy existentialism or astrology. If I thought that core Christian doctrine entailed that men and women were different in this way--which I don't--that would be a reducio for me.

It is also too culturally alien: different saints and different stories, a history that isn't my history and a different religious sensibility. It isn't on my culture tree. I might have become enculturated if I'd joined as an undergraduate but too late now because Anglicanism is flesh of my flesh and bone of my bone.

I suppose that's a peculiarity of mine. I connect to histories and to places. After spending most of my adult life in California I am still not connected, but when I go back east I am home. Last year at a conference in Baltimore I woke up and looked out the window. There were bits of slushy snow on the ground and bare, brown trees--I almost wept: this was my biome, the way land should look, the kind of plants that should grow outside. (One of the first thing that struck me when I came to Southern California was that there were houseplants growing outside). When I go back to England I feel even deeper into my history and when got to Italy almost 2 years ago I was overwhelmed with the sense that this was the root: the place where my culture began.

I am, of course, attracted to Orthodoxy because I'm a nut on Byzantine history and architecture. My visit to Italy was part of my drang nach abenland--a pilgrimage to the Hagia Sophia with side trips to all the domes I could catch along the way, including a number of churches in Greece as well as St. Paul's, the cathedral in Florence and San Marco. Once we got to Greece though I immediately recognized that I was out of my culture. The churches were wonderful but alien. They used space differently, without the focus one finds in western churches. With the altar behind the iconastasis, every place was equally holy. The central dome was just one of many domes and half-domes that was part of the bubble wrap. In one church I saw an old lady go up the stairs to kiss icons on the iconastasis--no sense that this part of the church was any holier than any other part. When I got back to England and to St. Paul's again I was stuck by how uncompromisingly western it was--all about the division between sacred and profane, movement, striving and power. There was no doubt whatsoever where the holy end was and you couldn't get within 10 feet of the high altar. It was going from Russian chant--warm, thick and homogeneous--to the Bach B Minor Mass.

I couldn't be authentically Orthodox--neither can most Americans any more than they could be authentically Hindu. However much we may romanticize it--and few people are as romantically attracted to all things Byzantine than I am--it simply isn't a cultural possibility, or a religious possibility to the extent that we're formed in a western tradition.

It stinks that the Episcopal Church, which has within its tradition the resources to be the heaven on earth Mr. Oren recognized in that Orthodox church he visited, has thrown that away. Disappointed and angry as I am, I still believe that Anglicanism is in principle Christianity in its ideal form. This is not a liturgical church but the liturgical church, which possesses the richest liturgy on earth because, like the English language, it has absorbed everything: everything western/Latin Christianity had and Anglican chant and Protestant hymnody and, in the 1982 hymnal, negro spirituals and chants from Eastern Orthodox sources. It has the biggest vocabulary, not only in its liturgy but in its history, literature and what I suppose could be called "spirituality."

Now the church is collapsing because the people who run it don't believe that religion is important or even interesting and are, in any case, convinced that it doesn't sell.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

The folks at TitusOneNine seem to have picked this up as well.

Some of the comments are interesting, though of course in a different vein than your own.

TWH

H. E. said...

Interesting--thanks for the heads-up. Interesting because there's sooo much backstory behind those comments. I've met Kendall Harmon and I've bumped into Al Kimel on several occasions. In addition to his ordinary earthly quirks Kimel also has the strange habit of conducting private conversations in blogs and other public facilities on the internet. In the way that I just did.

I'm curious about this ecumenical venture in which Nashota House and St. Vladimir's are involved. In one way it isn't a surprise because Nashota is the epicenter of ultra-Anglo-Catholicity: half the inmates want to be RC and the other half want to be Orthodox. In another way it's, well, interesting because, as an epicenter of ultra-Anglo-Catholicity at least 90% of the inmates are gay.

Anonymous said...

I hadn't heard that about gays at Nashotah; might one ask in a friendly way how the (presumably-approximate) figute of 90% was arrived at?

I seem to have the same sort of love/hate attitude towards Anglicanism that you do, though I've never actually taken the plunge.

On paper it seems like the best combination of Reason and Beauty that's possible for Western Christianity.

The reality seems to be a mixture of vicious bureaucrats, amateur social activists (wide spectrum), middlebrow poseurs and a gay mafia, with a quirky sprinkling of aesthetes, intellectuals and academics, all embedded in the usual matrix of talking-monkey politics and hell-bent on destroying the village in order to save it.

Very sad.

TWH

H. E. said...

90% is poetic license, but I don't think 50% would be too wildly out. I've known quite a few graduates who reminisce about seminary days and one longtime faculty member.

From their stories I get the impression that at least in the good old days Nashota cultivated a quasi-monastic image: just guys doing their Anglo-Catholic thing--not the sort of seminary where you have married students baracks or play groups for the kiddies, much less wannabe matushkas hanging out.

Anonymous said...

台中禾雅堂經典乳酪蛋糕提供精緻與上等食材製作出風味與口感覺佳之乳酪蛋糕及多種口味,無論是自用贈禮兩相宜,更是彌月蛋糕禮盒最佳選擇,歡迎參觀與選購.
台中乳酪蛋糕
chocolate
彌月蛋糕
乳酪蛋糕
巧克力
蛋糕

Anonymous said...

隔熱紙-汽車隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙 3M隔熱紙
3M隔熱紙-大樓隔熱紙 隔熱紙 汽車隔熱紙
汽車隔熱紙-隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙 3M隔熱紙
大樓隔熱紙-隔熱紙 汽車隔熱紙 3M隔熱紙
隔熱紙常識-隔熱紙 汽車隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙 3M隔熱紙
隔熱紙常識-隔熱紙 汽車隔熱紙 大樓隔熱紙 3M隔熱紙

Anonymous said...

您想結婚媽!!!

十年大陸新娘越南新娘介紹經驗,合法的婚姻介紹機構,嚴肅,專業的婚姻介紹網站,擁有臺灣多加外籍新娘婚姻協會人員合作,本網站是由大陸當地臺灣媒人所設立,位於廣西省,臨近越南河內,娶外籍新娘通過本站直接到異國娶親,省掉臺灣外籍新娘婚姻仲介中間環節,可以節省費用,全台各地都有我們所服務過的客人,如有需要可以提供電話詢問,我們的口碑經得起檢驗,也可為你推薦臺灣合法信譽好的婚姻協會人員為您服務,希望通過我們讓你以最經濟實惠的方式找到理想的伴侶,能夠為有緣人牽線搭橋,異國姻緣一線牽,歡迎以婚姻為目的,具備嚴肅婚姻心態,有責任感,有心想娶外籍新娘的臺灣單身男士與我們聯繫,我們將誠心為您服務!

大陸新娘 外籍新娘 越南新娘 中國新娘優質婚姻網站

Anonymous said...

正享除蟲服務項目:白蟻防治 跳蚤防治 蛀蟲 燻蒸防治 蟑螂防治 老鼠防治 蚊子防治 蒼蠅防治 螞蟻防治 蛾蚋防治 園藝防治
正享是專業的白蟻白蟻防治、除蟲專家,提供消除白蟻、白蟻防治、以及除蟲服務,只要您有惱人的白蟻困擾,找正享除蟲就對了。

Anonymous said...

正享除蟲服務項目:白蟻防治 跳蚤防治 蛀蟲 燻蒸防治 蟑螂防治 老鼠防治 蚊子防治 蒼蠅防治 螞蟻防治 蛾蚋防治 園藝防治
正享是專業的白蟻白蟻防治、除蟲專家,提供消除白蟻、白蟻防治、以及除蟲服務,只要您有惱人的白蟻困擾,找正享除蟲就對了。

eda said...

按摩棒,電動按摩棒,飛機杯,自慰套,自慰套,情趣用品,情趣內衣,
角色扮演,按摩棒,跳蛋,情趣跳蛋,

G點,性感丁字褲,情趣,角色扮演服,吊帶襪,丁字褲,無線跳蛋,

情趣,情趣用品,衣蝶,
色情小說|七夕情人,一夜情,

情趣按摩棒,.,
潤滑液,SM,內衣,性感內衣,自慰器,充氣娃娃,AV,

gaohui said...

Unconventional women don't ed hardy often fit into more ed hardy shoes conventional sizes. Instead, they are ed hardy clothing faced with the challenge of finding comfortable ed hardy clothes and stylish plus size women's clothing. By and large, most ed hardy store store refuse to stock sizes in ed hardy Bikini excess of a size 14 ed hardy swimsuits or 16. This means they have ed hardy Caps to find the clothes they need in specialty buy ed hardy store that can be very expensive. What then ed hardy swimwear is a plus size ed hardy sale woman to do? She has to do ed hardy glasses her research and find the cheap ed hardy places, both online and Christian audigier off, that will accommodate her wardrobe.